A MONSTER
CALLS
It is important to note that Siobhan Dowd has died of
cancer before she could even write the book herself. Patrick Ness has had the
privilege to do it for her, borrowing her ideas and trying to copy her voice. This
is the first time I’ve read something by Patrick Ness, and I haven’t read
anything by Siobhan Dowd, so I’m not sure in which voice A Monster Calls has
been really written. But directly copying the voice of another writer somewhat
defeats the purpose of expression in writing, not to mention that an absolute
copy is practically impossible. So I think A Monster Calls has been written in
a voice that transcends either of the two writers.
The book’s prose is very lyrical, but not in a way that
makes it pretentiously profound. It also has a dark tone to it. The words used
are simplistic and the dialogues are not formal, balancing the dark tone and
making the style appropriate for children despite the gloomy undertones.
There is a constant sense of struggle lingering between
the paragraphs, because the conflicts are not presented in a direct way and let
readers read between the lines to understand where that lingering sense of
struggle is coming from. The prose also knows how to conceal and suspend plot
elements without appearing to be intentionally delaying the events just to
increase the word count.
The structure of the story is also commendable. Aside
from the constant sense of struggle, there are a lot of conflicts scattered
throughout the book, to keep things turning and therefore interesting. Each
chapter is less than ten pages, so those with short attention spans will have
no problem leafing through the book. Each chapter also ends in a somewhat
poetic way that will make the readers jump to the next chapter. The almost
instant gratification from the short chapters actually makes this book easy to
read in one to two sessions.
The characters of the book are usual archetypes. We have
the loner boy, the gentle mother, the somewhat irresponsible father, the grandmother
with a strong personality, the bully, and the lone friend. But the important
thing is that they get the ideas of the book across. They are the perfect characters
for such a story and message. Another commendable thing is the distinctiveness
of each one’s voices, and that shows the difference in their personalities.
As for the illustrations, I think they match the tone of
the prose, if they do not set the atmosphere of the book singlehandedly. Jim
Kay knows how to utilize his blacks and whites, rendering them dark yet not
dark enough to be inappropriate for children. If I could compare it to anything,
it is to Dave McKean’s illustrations for Neil Gaiman’s The Graveyard Book.
Overall, A Monster Calls is an amazing read. It is dark
and lyrical yet suitable for all ages. It presents reality in quasi-fantastical
ways that will capture both the realist and surrealist. The messages it is
trying to tell also says something about the complexity of human nature, and life
and death themselves. Recommended read to everyone.
Additional note: If you want to read something similar, you can try Neil Gaiman’s The Graveyard Book. You can find my review of it here.
No comments:
Post a Comment