THE
HUNGER GAMES: This book is overrated
The
Hunger Games is one of the most overrated YA books among all overrated YA books
in contemporary fiction. I’m sorry, but this is just another Twilight -- the
kind of book that your friends desperately ask you to read but turns out to be crap.
The book has some interesting ideas, but it fails to grab my attention because
the prose is very bland; the descriptions are very cinematic and flat; and the
overuse of short, snappy sentences and fragments makes the flow of words very
rough.
Even
if I put the style aside, the book is still not impressive. The fictional world
follows a small amount of rules, and, as a result, there is plenty of room for
deus ex machina. The author weaves in too many coincidences in the story that
they feel like a dull solution to conflicts. To top it all off, certain plot
points that should have happened are excluded. It is as if the author is afraid
that she wouldn’t be able to pull them off. So she cops out. And I feel cheated.
So,
why is The Hunger Games so popular even though it has a weak plot and a flat prose?
What is it about poor writing that captivates readers? It is convenience. The
Hunger Games is so easy to read. The sentences are, at best, middle grade. To
tell the truth, even middle graders can write better than this! The author utilizes
this mindless writing style to tell a ‘suspenseful’ story, and poof! She has a
bestseller. It just shows that society prefers books that are very cinematic,
easy to understand, and do not require deep thought, or, at the least, a long attention
span. We want everything to be straight to the point so much that, sometimes,
we are willing to sacrifice depth.
People
should stop saying that The Hunger Games is a masterpiece. It’s far from that.
It’s just a stupid book that pretends to be a social commentary, when, in fact,
it’s nothing but a typical YA novel -- poorly written, shallow, and full of teen
angst.
Despite this harsh review, I'm actually happy that this kind of book exists. It is a good way to get people in to reading. I'm just hoping that after reading this book, they would be able to move on to better ones.
ReplyDelete